8 Best Waterproof Mascaras That Won’t Run, Smudge or Smear




BEST VOLUMIZING WATERPROOF MASCARA

Pump’N’Volume Waterproof Mascara

DIOR
  • Perfect Beauty Lab scores for resisting runs
  • Top scores for volumizing and separating
  • More prone to flaking and clumping

Dior’s mascara was rated highest for volumizing, separating lashes and creating a gorgeous, natural look. Testers loved the thicker formula, noting that it made lashes look more defined and enhanced, though it’s more prone to flaking and clumping than other formulas as result. Testers say that it stood up to “moisturizing eye drops throughout the day,” “cutting up an onion and also having a tearful moment at church on Easter Sunday,” and Lab tests confirm: it earned perfect scores for its ability to resist running.

BEST WATERPROOF MASCARA FOR SEPARATING LASHES

Inimitable Waterproof Mascara

CHANEL
  • Top Beauty Lab scores for separating and lengthening lashes
  • Smooth, clump-free and water-resistant
  • Pricey
  • Very difficult to remove

This mascara received top separation and lengthening scores from testers and was a close second for volumizing in Lab tests. Testers found the brush easy to use with smooth, clump-free application and high impact in just one coat. It also received high scores for being non-irritating and water-resistant, though some testers commented that it smudged easily and rated it most difficult to remove.